For most of the twentieth century, the mechanical watch was an endangered object. Electric watches arrived in the 1950s, quartz calibres in the late 1960s, and within a decade the industry that had perfected the portable mechanical movement was reduced to a fraction of its former size. Thousands of firms disappeared. Swiss watchmaking employment collapsed. The conventional wisdom, at the time, was straightforward: nobody would choose a mechanism that a battery-powered crystal could beat for accuracy.
That prediction was reasonable and wrong. The mechanical watch survived, and then it prospered — not as a tool, but as something else entirely. Understanding how that happened explains much of what the luxury watch market is today.
The quartz challenge, in brief
Quartz technology solved the problem watches were invented to solve: knowing the time accurately. A vibrating quartz crystal, regulated by an electronic circuit, keeps time better than any escapement of the era, at a fraction of the cost, with none of the winding or servicing. From an engineering standpoint the argument was settled by the early 1980s.
What the prediction missed was that watches had quietly stopped being primarily instruments. They had become among the last universally worn objects that carry meaning — signs of occasion, inheritance, taste, affiliation. An object whose value lies in meaning does not lose that value because a superior instrument exists. Nobody stopped wearing cufflinks because shirts got buttons.
What the survivors did differently
The firms that navigated those decades tend to share a few choices. They kept mechanical know-how alive even when demand vanished — preserving skills, tooling and apprenticeships that could not be cheaply rebuilt later. They repositioned the mechanical watch around what quartz could not offer: visible craft, kinetic complexity, longevity measured in generations rather than battery cycles. And they leaned into identity rather than utility, understanding that a luxury object must justify itself emotionally as well as technically.
The revival that followed — gathering pace through the late 1980s and 1990s — was driven substantially by complications that celebrate mechanism for its own sake: tourbillons, minute repeaters, perpetual calendars. These are rarely the most useful features to own. That is precisely the point. They demonstrate capability the way a grand prix engine demonstrates capability, and collectors respond to the demonstration.
Why the revival holds
Three properties keep the mechanical watch relevant in a world of ubiquitous, accurate, disposable time-telling.
- Permanence. A well-made movement is serviceable almost indefinitely; parts can be remade, wear can be corrected. Quartz electronics are sealed, cheap and disposable by design. Longevity is a luxury good in itself.
Craft visibility. A sapphire caseback turns the movement into a working exhibit: anglage on the bridges, perlage on the plates, the balance beating visibly. The watch is jewellery whose mechanism is the ornament.
Narrative. Mechanical watches carry centuries of horological history into an object you can wear. That story is part of what buyers pay for, and quartz never had a story worth telling.
The lesson for collectors
If you evaluate a mechanical watch purely as a timekeeping instrument, you are comparing it against a calculator it will lose to. The correct comparison is with other objects of craft — furniture, tools, garments made to be repaired — where quality of making, durability of service and coherence of design are the real measures. On those terms the mechanical watch did not survive the quartz age despite its obsolescence. It survived because of the values that obsolescence exposed.
Every article at Meridian & Stone is reviewed by an editor before publication. Details of our standards are set out in the Editorial Policy.